New TM list does not represent IRAN!!

[HoomanYZ]

Originally Posted by dashali

HOOMAN jan...
thanks for the compliment...I do not recall the Azarbayjan game and subs... but what I can add here is....I don't criticize Branko for using JABARI and and and....as a matter of fact, I am saying, he should have used more players and let DAEI, NEKOUNAM and GOLMOHAMMADI AND KAABI on the bench,,,,
I said before....I am not a writer....and maybe you mis-understood me....

In the months ahead of us....we need to give a chance to our players...other than who we know..... be ghoole khodemoon...bayad be in javoonha meydoon bedan, vagharneh footballe ma pieshraft nemiekoneh...

Iranetehhhhhhhhhhhh

Dashali jan,

I understood what you said here. It's my bad then. I thought you criticized him for that after Azerbayjan game. Should have mistaken you with someone else. In Azerbayjan game, the first half all our regular players played. Second half mostly the subs played. First half we scored two and had a relatively good performance. Second half, don't mention it. I personally thought that was the right decision since we had plenty of time till WC. We needed to give more experience to our young players. Result shouldn't have mattered. Today, however, there is not much time left. Clock is ticking and I think it is better to field few new players at a time. The problem is: We have probably only one more friendly with IFF's planning and political climate of Iran. I would have liked to see what you said, i.e. giving chances to more reserve players. But, when do our main players get a chance to become a cohesive unit? I think we are like a student who wants to prepare for exam the last night, and doesn't know which part of the book to read, because there is not enough time to read all of it. So, he has to take chances and read some part, and pray that the exam comes on that part, and he is able to answer the questions. Once again we are down to our old tactic: Praying for a miracle. LOL. The good thing is we have years of practice in this tactic.

ps. We used to say: taraf be toop mige ghAblame. fekr konam oonAii ke migan hendoone kheili bishtar dar morede toop ettelA'At dAran.

[fakhfour]

Originally Posted by dashali

either your English is not good or you are just ignorant person...

dashali jaan
I misunderstood your point about Mohajerani, and apologize for that.

But I still think that I don't need to be a coach, a player or a professional football-writer to express myself about my beloved TM! I would also like to add that I don't consider myself as an "ignorant person"!

dashali jaan, we should learn something which is more important than Branco, TM or football!!!

Voltaire says: "I do not agree with what you say, but I will fight until the end so that you can say it."

Vahid Fakhfouri

[Kaz]

It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it. - Aristotle

[dashali]

Originally Posted by Kaz

It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it. - Aristotle

NA shahshiedeh shab derazehhhhhhhhhh......
"Bachehaye TEHROON"

[PersianPlaya408]

Originally Posted by HoomanYZ

Dashali jan,

I hope you don't mind me jumping pAberahneh in your topic. lol. I agree with many of the points that you said. I think Madanchi should be our left back from now on, if he can keep up his form. ( Of course he needs to get a chance. ) Also, I think Daei should be on the bench playing last 20-30 minutes of the game if his services are needed ( depending on the game's dynamic). So, I am in agreement with a lot of what you said. I personally don't care about Taiwan's game. We need to think world cup only. I think you are right to ask that Branko needed to give a chance to the invited players, instead of using the already tested players over and over again. However, there is one point that confuses me. So, I am asking your opinion as a coach:

When Branko sent all our subs against Azebayjan, many of well respected IK members - including yourself if I am not mistaken - were calling for Branko's head. The argument was: This is his way to just shut people's mouth. He sends this players who have never played with each other in the second half to prove his main line up, used in first half was much better. He was accused of trying to fool people. Many of us asked him to include the two or three new players at a time, so that they can gel in the team, not put all of them in the pitch to have a shalam shoorba. This makes sense to me. This is also what Branko did in Taiwan game. Now you are criticizing him for not giving a chance to more players. ( Khatibi, Akbarpour, Madanchi, Jabbari, Teymourian) were all new players. That's 5 players. I am not including Kazemian because he has been on the team on and off. So, as a coach which approach do you suggest?

Great thread by the way. It opened a lot of good discussions. Eventhough I disagree with your title and think only Mobali should be added to this list. Therefore, I think this list pretty much represents the best Iran has.

hooman jan... i assume branko doesnt use madanchi in left back, because of reasons given by mehran molkara on jame jam broadcast of costa rica match... he said madanchi does not have defensive characteristics that Zareh has, although madanchi would be way way better in attack perspective, left back is a position that requires alot of defending as well, (kaabi has adjusted to become a great defender as well as attacker in recent years if you noticed).... i dont think we will see madanchi playing left back, although i would love it, i think he will be used primarily as a reserve for Zandi

[HoomanYZ]

Originally Posted by PersianPlaya408

hooman jan... i assume branko doesnt use madanchi in left back, because of reasons given by mehran molkara on jame jam broadcast of costa rica match... he said madanchi does not have defensive characteristics that Zareh has, although madanchi would be way way better in attack perspective, left back is a position that requires alot of defending as well, (kaabi has adjusted to become a great defender as well as attacker in recent years if you noticed).... i dont think we will see madanchi playing left back, although i would love it, i think he will be used primarily as a reserve for Zandi

PersianPlaya408 jan,

Thanks for the post. This might very well be the true reason Branko doesn't use Madanchi, but, this is too conservative for me. I think we should have given the chance to Madanchi to improve his defensive skills, just like he gave chance to Zare to improve his offensive skills. In Zare's case, it hasn't worked. The sad part is we never will find out if it would work for Madanchi, since we didn't give him enough chances.

[PersianPlaya408]

Originally Posted by HoomanYZ

PersianPlaya408 jan,

Thanks for the post. This might very well be the true reason Branko doesn't use Madanchi, but, this is too conservative for me. I think we should have given the chance to Madanchi to improve his defensive skills, just like he gave chance to Zare to improve his offensive skills. In Zare's case, it hasn't worked. The sad part is we never will find out if it would work for Madanchi, since we didn't give him enough chances.

agreed bro... my dream is to see madanchi in Left back... i just dont see it hapenning

[Exoma]

Originally Posted by PersianPlaya408

agreed bro... my dream is to see madanchi in Left back... i just dont see it hapenning

soon inshallah

[Keano]

Originally Posted by Exoma

soon inshallah

Ya ghamare bani haashem!

[Exoma]

Originally Posted by Keano

Ya ghamare bani haashem!

YA MOHAMMAD PEYGHAMBAREH BOZORG